- chlorine is the most widely used chemical disinfectant globally
- has been used for over a century
- beginning with UK and then US
- 98% of water treatment in US
- second most common treatment after boiling
- chlorine is a strong oxidant
- devastates cell walls, DNA, enzymes and organic compounds in general
- destruction mechanism not fully understood
- especially for viruses and protozoa
- not effective against Cryptosporidium
chlorine species
elemental chlorine (Cl gas)
- large water utility suppliers use this
- cost effective
- 100% chlorine (fully concentrated)
high test hypochlorite (HTH)
- powdery or tablet form
- 60% - 70% chlorine concentration
- used by large water utilities
bleaching powder (also chlorinated lime or calcium hypochlorite)
- another powdered form
- 15% - 35% chlorine
- isn’t stable chlorine, actual concentration varies widely
- dose calculation is difficult
household bleach
- solution of sodium hypochlorite
- usually 5% chlorine
- javel water is a similar product, typically bit less strong
DIY chlorine
- pass electric current through simple salt solution
- < 1% chlorine
adding to water
pH response
- when a chlorine source is added to water, it becomes hypochlorous acid (HOCl)
- HOCl loses a proton at higher pH and becomes hypochlorite or OCl
- these two species together are called “Free Chlorine”
- at pH 7.54, the two species are present in equal amounts
- at higher pH, hypochlorite dominates
- at lower pH, hypochlorous acid is the main species
- hypochlorous acid is the stronger disinfectant of the two
- water should have pH of less than 8 when chlorinated for disinfection
- to ensure reasonable amount of hypochlorous acid
chlorine demand
- chlorine is highly reactive, reacts with the chemicals naturally present in water
- the dose has to meet the chlorine demand of these reactions and
- the amount necessary to neutralize the pathogens
- chlorine demand may be caused by
- organic carbon (naturally present in surface water)
- iron (ground water)
- manganese (ground water)
- ammonia (ground water)
- target residual concentration: at least 0.5 mg/L of chlorine in water
- may require a dosage of 1-5 mg/L with 2mg/L fairly typical
turbidity
- reduces the effectiveness of chlorine both by shielding pathogens
- turbidity creates chlorine demand and wastes chlorine by reacting it away
- standard doses are doubled when turbidity is present
- ideally, the right dose is determined by trial and error for the desired residual
health risks
- chlorine doesn’t pose any health risks
- concentrated forms need careful handling however
- WHO lists a guideline value of 5 mg/L
- this is a conservative guideline
- already results in unacceptable tastes and odors at this level
- US Centers for Disease Control and Pan American Health Organization
- chlorine disinfection
- safe storage
- behavior change communication
- has been taken up latin america and parts of africa
- involves production of dilute sodium hypochlorite solution (0.75% free chlorine)
- hypochlorite form is more stable than hypochlorous acid
- are typically stabilized at pH 11 or greater
- for storage, household bleach pH is around 12
- it is slightly irritating to the skin
- bottle is designed such that one capful is good for local use containers
- one capful/20L water
- dose of at least 1.9 mg/L
- double if water is turbid
reservoir chlorine
- NaDCC
- sodium dichloroisocyanurate
- about 60% free chlorine
- used in swimming pools - reservoir chlorine
- guideline value of 40 mg/L
- doesn’t pose a health risk
- consistent free chlorine level
- less taste and odor
- because of the reservoir effect
- NaDCC tablets = effervescent tablets
- long shelf life
- 10 L: 1 X 33 mg tablet if clean, 2 if turbid
- 20 L: 1 X 67 mg tablet if clean, 2 if turbid
- easy-to-use
efficacy against pathogens
- dose = Concentration * time (Ct)
- recommended 0.5 mg/L, 30 min
- Ct = 15 min-mg/L
- equivalent to 1 mg/15 mins
- HWTS min concentration: 1.9 mg/L
- Ct_99: Ct value required for 99% pathogen kill
- 99% kill = 2 Log Reduction value
bacteria
- 0.04 LRV - 0.08 LRV
- spores are more resistant
viruses
- 2 LRV - 30 LRV
- takes longer for good removal
protozoa
- 25 LRV - 245 LRV
- very ineffective for cryptosporidium cysts
- not all protozoa are this resistant
- giardia has a Ct_99 of 15
combined chlorine
- free chlorine + ammonia = chloramines
- monochloramine
- dichloramine
- trichloramine
- strong odor: the swimming pool odor
- less efficient disinfectant
disinfection by-products
- residual chlorine reacts with organic carbon dissolved in water
- if high levels of carbon present
- leads to hazardous by-products
- organic carbon
- trihalomethanes (e.g. chloroform)
- haloacetic acids
- carcinogenic in lab animals at high concentrations
- guideline values
- justification is it is a much smaller risk compared to the major water borne diseases
other chemical alternatives
- chloramines
- chlorine dioxide
- ozone
- bromine
- silver
consideration
advantages
- highly effective against bacteria
- residual protection
- simple to use
- low cost
challenges
- ineffective against protozoa
- taste and odor
- requires low turbidity
- requires supply chain
- misunderstanding about by-products